ADHD vs. Depression in NJ Adults: Why the Difference Is Hard to Spot

/in , ,

ADHD and depression show up together often enough that treating one alone usually leaves half the problem still standing. Depression usually gets caught first, since it is the more familiar diagnosis. The ADHD underneath can stay unnamed for years.

A man tells us his exhaustion was written off as depression for years. He mentions that an evaluation finally found ADHD sitting underneath it the whole time. ADHD and depression overlap so closely that one gets found while the other stays hidden.

Adults with ADHD are diagnosed with major depression at a much higher rate than adults without it. That difference is large enough to raise a second question about what might be sitting underneath it. A full evaluation asks about both, rather than stopping at whichever one showed up loudest. A full adult ADHD evaluation in NJ can look at what else might be part of the story.

Why Depression Usually Gets Found First

Depression has a familiar checklist. Low mood, loss of interest, trouble sleeping, and fatigue are questions most doctors ask as standard practice. A nine-question depression screening tool sits in nearly every primary care intake packet.

CHADD, citing the National Comorbidity Survey Replication, puts the rate of major depression among adults with ADHD at 18.6 percent. That compares with 7.8 percent of adults without ADHD. ADHD does not have an equivalent screening tool sitting in that same intake packet.

ADHD in adults usually does not get the same treatment. Few primary care visits include a question about childhood focus or follow-through. If someone was never evaluated as a child, nobody thinks to ask about it as an adult.

The result is an order-of-discovery problem. Whichever condition gets screened for gets found first. A patient walks in exhausted and low.

A depression screening catches the exhaustion and the low mood. Nobody asks whether the exhaustion goes back to childhood, or whether staying organized has always been a fight. Whichever condition shows up loudest in the appointment gets treated, while the other keeps running underneath, unnoticed. Years can pass this way before anyone connects the two.

The Symptoms That Get Confused

ADHD causes task avoidance that can look identical to low motivation from across a desk. Depression causes that same low motivation, along with a loss of interest in things that used to feel worthwhile. Starting a boring task can feel nearly impossible either way.

Depression causes fatigue that does not lift with rest. ADHD burnout causes a similar exhaustion, built from years of pushing through the daily mess and hiding symptoms at work. A tired, unmotivated adult can walk out with a depression diagnosis.

Depression causes feelings of worthlessness. Rejection sensitive dysphoria, common in ADHD, produces a similar wave of shame after a small criticism or a mistake. The two can look the same in a short appointment, even though what causes them is completely different.

Concentration problems show up in both conditions too. A depressed mind slows down and struggles to focus on anything, even things that used to feel easy. An ADHD mind wanders toward whatever is more interesting than the task at hand. From across a desk, both look like someone who cannot concentrate.

Why Treating Only the Depression Falls Short

Mood can lift while the disorganization, missed deadlines, and lost keys stay right where they were. That is what happens when an antidepressant treats only the depression. Many adults describe that same kind of partial improvement. Sadness eases, but the chaos underneath stays the same.

Research published through the National Institutes of Health found that only about 10 percent of adults with ADHD receive treatment. That is far lower than the treatment rate for mood disorders. This difference helps explain why so many adults get a mood diagnosis and stop there.

Most antidepressants target mood chemistry. They were never built to fix time blindness, a buried inbox, or a desk that never stays clear. ADHD and burnout go hand in hand, it can feel like something that never resolves with rest or antidepressants alone.

How to Tell Them Apart

One test is whether mood lifts during something engaging, even briefly. Depression usually flattens interest across the board, regardless of what someone tries.

ADHD-driven low mood usually brightens the moment something absorbing shows up. Attention still responds to stimulation even when mood is struggling.

A second test looks backward instead of forward. Depression can start at any age. It usually has a clear starting point tied to a loss or a hard stretch of life.

ADHD traces back further, into childhood struggles with organization, focus, or sitting still. Nobody may have used that word at the time.

A third test is what happens on a good day. Someone with depression alone can wake up rested and still feel flat and unmotivated. Untreated ADHD can feel sharper on a good day. The same mess and missed details keep showing up regardless of mood.

When Both Are Present at Once

Sometimes the honest answer is not one or the other. Depression and ADHD can grow side by side. Years of struggle with untreated ADHD can wear down someone’s confidence. A real depressive episode can set in on top of it. Emotional intensity plays a role here too. Adults managing both conditions describe experiencing more mood swings with ADHD than they used to.

Treating both at once usually works better than treating them one at a time. A prescriber managing both conditions can sequence medication with care.

What Adults Ask About ADHD and Depression

Can ADHD medication make depression worse? Yes, for some people, especially with certain stimulants at certain doses. This is a question for a prescriber managing both conditions, not a reason to avoid treatment altogether.

Does treating ADHD improve depression on its own? Sometimes, at least partly. When years of ADHD-driven failure were feeding the depression, treating the ADHD can lift some of that weight too. Depression that exists on its own usually still needs its own treatment.

Is it common for depression to be caught years before ADHD is? Yes. Many adults spend years in depression treatment before anyone asks about a childhood history of inattention. That delay is common enough that catching it now is not a personal failure.

What should someone bring up at their next appointment? A history of focus problems going back to childhood, even if it was never diagnosed, whether mood ever lifts around interesting work, and whether medication has improved sadness without touching the daily mess.

Should someone stop their antidepressant before getting checked for ADHD? No. Keep taking current medication as prescribed and raise the question at the next appointment instead of stopping anything alone.

Looking at Both, Not Just the Loudest One

ADHD and depression overlap closely enough that treating one alone usually leaves the other running in the background. Depression usually gets found first because it is the condition most clinicians are trained to look for.

Sources

How to Talk to Your Child About School Shootings

/in , , ,

Sadly school shootings have become normative in our culture and parents are faced with the question of how and when to talk to their kids about being safe in school. Here are a few tips and resources to help parents navigate these discussions:
1. Keep discussions age appropriate. Younger children need more reassurance and less specific information. They may have questions about active shooter drills or why there was a school walkout. Keep information short and age appropriate and reassure your child that adults are always taking measures to keep students safe. Older kids and teenagers will want to talk more and may want to get more involved in advocacy efforts. Make sure to make time to talk and practice reflective listening. Echo back their concerns and ideas.
2. Limit exposure to the news. News tends to refresh and replay the same upsetting images and soundbytes. Exposure to these stories via television or on the radio can be upsetting and confusing for children. Also, keep an eye out for newsfeeds that come up as ads or pop-ups on social media. Your child may be watching news footage unbeknownst to you.
3. Pay attention. Know the signs of stress or anxiety in your child. Pay attention to changes in behavior such as excessive worry, nightmares or sleep disruptions. Consider reaching out to a qualified child mental health professional if you see any of these symptoms for an extended period.
4. Stay on top of what is happening locally. Follow and attend school board meetings, talk to your child’s school principal or administrator. In the wake of the latest shooting at Parkland, many school districts have made changes to their safety policy. Share this information with your child as well as with other caregivers so that they can be prepared for changes in school visitation or pickup policies.
5. Stay connected. Encouraging regular communication with your child is the best way to know what’s going on in your child’s school . Consider scheduling a regular time to meet with your child to discuss any concerns they may have. Creating an environment of open communication will beget open communication.

Resources for parents:

Check out this recent piece which was featured in Time magazine by Dr. Ross Greene:
https://www.livesinthebalance.org/Nineteen-years-tragedy

The Depressed Child

/in ,

Not only adults become depressed. Children and teenagers also may have depression, which is a treatable illness. Depression is defined as an illness when the feelings of depression persist and interfere with a child or adolescent’s ability to function.

About 5 percent of children and adolescents in the general population suffer from depression at any given point in time. Children under stress, who experience loss, or who have attentional, learning, conduct or anxiety disorders are at a higher risk for depression. Depression also tends to run in families. The behavior of depressed children and teenagers may differ from the behavior of depressed adults. Child and adolescent psychiatrists advise parents to be aware of signs of depression in their youngsters.

If one or more of these signs of depression persist, parents should seek help:

  • Frequent sadness, tearfulness, crying
  • Hopelessness
  • Decreased interest in activities; or inability to enjoy previously favorite activities
  • Persistent boredom; low energy
  • Social isolation, poor communication
  • Low self esteem and guilt
  • Extreme sensitivity to rejection or failure
  • Increased irritability, anger, or hostility
  • Difficulty with relationships
  • Frequent complaints of physical illnesses such as headaches and stomachaches
  • Frequent absences from school or poor performance in school
  • Poor concentration
  • A major change in eating and/or sleeping patterns
  • Talk of or efforts to run away from home
  • Thoughts or expressions of suicide or self destructive behavior

A child who used to play often with friends may now spend most of the time alone and without interests. Things that were once fun now bring little joy to the depressed child. Children and adolescents who are depressed may say they want to be dead or may talk about suicide. Depressed children and adolescents are at increased risk for committing suicide. Depressed adolescents may abuse alcohol or other drugs as a way to feel better.

Children and adolescents who cause trouble at home or at school may also be suffering from depression. Because the youngster may not always seem sad, parents and teachers may not realize that troublesome behavior is a sign of depression. When asked directly, these children can sometimes state they are unhappy or sad.

Early diagnosis and treatment are essential for depressed children. Depression is a real illness that requires professional help. Comprehensive treatment often includes both individual and family therapy. For example, cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and interpersonal psychotherapy (IPT) are forms of individual therapy shown to be effective in treating depression. Treatment may also include the use of antidepressant medication. For help, parents should ask their physician to refer them to a qualified mental health professional, who can diagnose and treat depression in children and teenagers.

Re-printed with Permission from American Academy of Child & Adolesccent Psychiatry